West Indies and Afghanistan have met 23 times across all international formats — Test cricket, One-Day Internationals and Twenty20 Internationals. West Indies have won 14 of those encounters (61%) while Afghanistan have claimed 9 victories (39%). West Indies currently hold the overall head-to-head advantage in this rivalry.

In the longest format, West Indies have won 0 Tests against Afghanistan's 1 (from 1 Tests played). Test cricket is the most demanding arena for a bilateral rivalry — each five-day match requires batting depth, bowling variety across conditions and the mental stamina to grind through long sessions. A strong Test record typically reflects the quality of each nation's domestic first-class pathway and the ability of senior batters to perform over five days in conditions that may suit the opposition.

In One-Day Internationals, West Indies lead 6–4 from 10matches played. ODI cricket rewards balanced squads capable of both setting and chasing totals in excess of 300 — the powerplay and middle-overs phases demand specialist skills from batters and bowlers alike, and the format's 50-over length gives selectors room to pick a bowling attack covering pace, swing, spin and death-overs precision.

In Twenty20 Internationals, West Indies hold a 8–4 advantage across 12 matches. T20Is compress a cricket contest into roughly three hours, placing a premium on explosive batting in the powerplay, smart middle-overs rotation and death-bowling execution. The short format also narrows the margin between squads — a single outstanding individual spell or innings can shift a T20I result in ways that rarely happen across five days of Test cricket.

Head-to-head records in cricket shift across eras as coaching philosophies, squad depth and pitch conditions evolve. A team that dominated bilateral series in the 1980s and 1990s may carry a heavy overall lead against an opponent that has been consistently stronger in recent campaigns. The total matches count on this page folds decades of history into the cumulative numbers: reading the record alongside the format-by-format breakdown gives the clearest picture of current competitive balance rather than long-run historical advantage. Form, home advantage and tournament context also weigh heavily on any individual series result.